1865 Fancy 5 Indian Cent, Pretty MS64BN PCGS. We liked this coin for the color and nice bold strike despite a couple of minor spots. We would not have bought it for the next grade up, however. The Fancy 5 date is quite popular, although this is not a piece we will hold onto forever. Note how well all the feather tips are struck up. The PCGS Price Guide is, as typical for nicely toned copper, considerably under the mark.