1875 Indian Cent MS64RB PCGS CAC Popular Date! The mid-1870s Indian cents are renowned for being difficult to find in top grades, and fortunately at VDB Coins we have a nice selection of them! This one is just a little above Greysheet Bid, which is $500. PCGS Guide is $650. We took the photo before sending it to CAC, but it’s got the CAC approval.